Resilience for Whom? A Tier Exposure Constraint for Supply Chain Network Design under Cascading Disruption
Author : Mahmood Abdulsattar Ahmad, Dr. Areej Aftab Siddiqui, Dr. Sania Ashraf
Abstract : Supply chain resilience is normally measured on a throughput variable of the focal firm or the aggregate network. We show that such measures are systematically biased in networks with steep inter-tier power asymmetry, because the cheapest available adjustment channel is the one they cannot observe. We formalise a downstream cost cascade in which unabsorbed disruption cost is transferred along supplier tiers, give its closed form through a Neumann series on a transfer matrix, and define a tier exposure ratio R as the ratio of unabsorbed cost per unit of revenue at the lower tier to the same quantity at the focal tier. We prove that focal-tier time to recovery is non-increasing in the transfer share while R is strictly increasing in it, so measured resilience improves exactly as lower-tier fragility worsens. We then embed R in a two-stage stochastic network design model as a design-stage constraint, with the conventional cost-minimising design nested as a special case. Evidence from India across four cascading disruptions between 2018 and 2024 shows large and stable tier divergence: four to six months to recovery at the focal tier against ten to fourteen below it, and formal trade finance access of approximately 89 against 41 per cent. A computational study prices the constraint: R falls from 4.43 to 1.00 for 0.09 per cent of expected total network cost, and closing the workforce adjustment channel moves the cost minimising transfer share from 0.605 to 0.040
Keywords : Supply chain resilience, network design, stochastic programming, cascading disruption, multi-tier supply networks, tier exposure, emerging markets.
Conference Name : International Conference on Operations Research and Supply Chain Design (ICORSCD - 26)
Conference Place : Giza, Egypt
Conference Date : 28th Oct 2026